I'm so excited about this! The list of my co-panelists looks fantastic.
I was on this panel not last year but the year before (2009) and it was a fantastic experience. It was Graphic Novel immersion and I learned so much. This year I'm thrilled to be back with that knowledge.
I'll be working closely with
- Kyle at The Boy Reader
- Melissa (my name cousin!) who blogs Here in the Bonny Glen
- Liz of lizjonesbooks
- Megan of Devour Books
- Alyssa (my name twinner!) in The Shady Glade
- and Christina, Guerilla Librarian
You (yes, you!) can nominate your favorite graphic novel published in the past year. I and my fellow panelists will read all the nominees and create a shortlist of titles to pass on to the Round Two judges. They'll pick the year's best graphic novels (one for YA, one for Kids) based on Kid Appeal and Literary Merit.
Of course you can also nominate your favorite books of the year that fall in other categories (not just graphic novels). Nominations open on October 1, and I'll be sure to post a link to the nomination form. (EDIT: Here is the link!)For round one, each book nominated is read by two panelists. They read at least the first fifty pages of the book and evaluate it based on the Cybils criteria -- kid appeal and literary merit. In my experience, nearly all of the books are read completely by more than two panelists. We have a great time debating the merits of the nominees via emails and group chats, and inevitably come up with a list of stellar books.
Just itching to start,