Quantcast

Thursday, February 4, 2016

My Kid Reads Too Much! One Important Question + 13 tips

Hi there! I'm Alysa.

You're reading this post because you have a child who READS TOO MUCH, right? Your precious offspring has been sucked in by book after book and you want to know how you can get your child back. What happened to those halcyon days when you read your baby bedtime stories? Those days when you said "that's enough for tonight" and your kid didn't wake up in the morning with a Harry Potter Hangover and a stolen flashlight with dead batteries?!

Well. You CAN bring your kid back to the real world. I know you can do it, and I know how you can do it. In my youth, I was one of these children! And not only that, I have a bookworm of my own -- an eight-year-old who reads multiple chapter books a day if I let my guard down.


Ashley told me her 11-year-old niece Emily is really into reading and that Emily's mom, Debi, is suffering from Emily's bibliophilia.

I confess that when I first heard "My kid is reading too much!" my reaction was "Impossible. Reading is a good thing."

But I thought about it, and there really is a limit to how much a kid should read. You want to raise a successful adult who happens to be a bookworm, not a slob who can't communicate and hides behind books.

It would be simple to say "Grow a backbone! Limit your child's reading and stick to that limit." But that's not helpful.
How do you limit reading? 
How do you know how much is too much?

The answer is different for everybody, so before I dive into some examples I'm going to give you the the big question you need to guide you.

The Big Question: 
WHY do you think your child is reading too much?

When you think about this deeply and answer it honestly, potential solutions are much easier to find.

Here are some of the reasons you might come up with, and ideas for each.

1. I can't keep up with what she's reading! Is she reading garbage that will harm her soul? Is she reading books that are a waste of time?

If you're worried about what she's reading, your essential concern is "This might be dangerous." My advice is to take the time to find out if it really is dangerous or not. Here are some ways you can do that.



  • Ask her about it. Would this be a good book for me? Why, or why not? Would this be a good book for your little sister? Why, or why not? Did anyone in the book do something that you would not do? Did anyone do something you admire and would want to do yourself?
  • Require her to keep a book log. Just the title and author of each book should be enough. You can reward her for logging books, if she's too busy reading to write them down. You could even make a game of it. If one of our family members sees you reading a book and writes it on the log before you do, they get the reward!
  • Look at reviews online. If you have title and author info, this is fairly simple. You can try a site like Amazon or Goodreads, which will have reviews from a large variety of users. Or you can find a book reviewer you trust who reviews loads of books. Ms. Yingling Reads and Jean Little Library are two book blogs I trust for middle grade recommendations, and of course you can use the search function here on Everead anytime you'd like. 
  • Ask a friend about the books she is reading. I'm happy to be that friend. (Sign up for my email list and make it easy for us to chat!) The other day I was talking to a friend of mine and she was complaining that her son's class was studying the Percy Jackson books. I asked her why that worried her. She said that her son had already read the books, and that when she flipped through them they seemed to be just one violent episode after another. I assured her that I had read the books and that they were solid. They're the kind of books that a class could study and get something out of, even if it's not your son's first read-through. Also, I thought carefully about her violence concerns and once I had considered the books and what I know about her son and her family, I didn't think they were inappropriate in any way. The Percy Jackson books are fast paced, and there is plenty of fantasy violence, but they're explicitly teaching against violent behavior and advocating for good values of friendship and loyalty and being kind to others who aren't like you. So, take some time to talk with a friend, or phone your local children's or teen librarian and discuss your concerns. You may be pleasantly surprised about what she's reading. And if you're getting warning signals from the adults of the kidlit community, you'll have some specifics to talk to your daughter about.
  • Teach her about danger in books. What things do you think "cross the line?" Talk to your daughter about what you think, and ask her what she thinks. You could even say something like "At some point you'll probably run into [swearing/sex/violence/whatever it is], when you do, will you talk to me about it? Together we can see if you thought it was handled well and made the book better, or handled badly and made the book less likable." Don't shame her for coming across bad material in books. We've all picked out something that looked innocent but turned out to be too much. Instead of criticizing, use these times to teach her how to be a discerning reader.



2. I can't get her to help out! As soon as I turn my back she's reading again. Her room is a mess, her chores aren't done, she hasn't practiced piano...

If you can't get her to help out around the house, you have some unmet expectations.


  • Make sure your expectations are clear. I just posted a new chart for my kids. It seems like after a little while we stop seeing our old reminders, and I think that's just human nature. We need to refresh and reset often. These charts tell my kids that if I catch them reading before their duties are done and make them stop there is no complaining allowed. They must complete the list before they can GO.
  • Keep free time free. If you catch her reading and you're annoyed because you think she should be doing something else, ask yourself if that's true. Should she be doing something else just because you think she should, or should she be doing something else because she really is neglecting some other essential area of life? Remind her that there are many types of time at home. If it's "free time" let it be free and let her choose to read. If it's not free time but "family time" then tell her "this is family time," "this is game time," or "this is helping time." If free time is coming to an end, you can help her transition away from her book by saying things like "Find a good stopping place, soon." This is courteous, in the same way that knocking on a door before you enter is nice. It takes a little bit of the edge off of the shock of having to come back to reality. Another thing you can do is ask her about her book once she finally puts it down. I know first hand that reading a good book keeps you thinking about that book, that subject or that world. And having someone ask me about my book is a great way to transition from thinking about the book to thinking about what's going on around me. 



3. I want more time with her! I have to be doing my own household duties, but any time I wish I could chat with her while I scrub pots, she is reading.

If you want her to spend more time with you (or other family members), you've got two basic options: spend time together not reading, and spend time together reading.

  • Make non-reading time an expectation. For instance, put "chat with mom for 10 minutes" on the list of things she has to do before free time. Or make up stories together. Require your daughter to tell you about her day at school, but as if she were a character from one of her books. Engage her imagination outside of books. Help her see the drama and the stories that are part of life around her.
  • Spend time reading as a family. Listen to audiobooks together in the car or while you work on household jobs. Read to each other during mealtimes. 



4. I'm worried she's not learning important skills she needs. I know you can learn by reading, but some things are learned by practice. She's not practicing those things!

If you're worried she's reading instead of practicing life skills, define those skills.


click to shop
  • Make a plan.  I've been reading a great book about this called The Parenting Breakthrough: A Real-life Plan to Teach Your Kids to Work, Save Money, and Be Truly Independent by Merrilee Browne Boyack. It's targeted to an LDS audience, but I think it has valuable information for parents regardless of whether or not you belong to the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. For one thing, it has a great list of things that children should be able to do at each age from 3-18. Boyack suggests that 11-year-olds should be arranging for their own haircuts. What a great idea! That's the kind of task that an 11-year-old probably has all the skills to complete, but most of us haven't thought of assigning it to her. 



5. She's not getting enough sleep! She stays up all night reading and in the morning she is grouchy and slow.

If your child isn't getting enough sleep, I recommend doing all three of the following things. Sleep is serious!

  • Check in. Of course she is going to get better sleep if you check on her now and then, and remind her to turn off the light. 11-year-olds still need their parents and they still need accountability. But we want to "teach them how to fish," too. We want to teach our kids to go to sleep without us, eventually. 


click to shop
  • Teach her how to go to sleep on her own. I found some good advice on how to do this in what is probably the most famous kids sleep book, Healthy Sleep Habits, Happy Child by Marc Weissbluth. I have translated that advice into this little poster, which hangs by my kids' light switch. Something like this might be helpful for an 11-year-old, as long as you don't shame her for not knowing how to do it already. Start from where you are and try to help her feel like following these rules at a reasonable hour will help improve her life. 
  • Help her experiment to find out how much sleep she actually needs. A quick search told me that 11-year-olds need between 9-11 hours of sleep each night. Well, that is a two hour range! And your 11-year-old would probably be thrilled to try out some different bedtimes, and different amounts of evening reading time, with your assistance. 



I think we could go on here. But I also think that parenting is something that is most effective when it is between the parents and the child. You know your child. You know their limits and your limits. By now you know that what used to work might not work anymore, and that when something doesn't work, thoughtful parents try a different tactic. It's worth it to raise kids who are successful, independent adults!

That said, I think we can leave this post open for comments. What other reasons can you think of to answer The Big Question? What other advice do you have for parents who feel their kids are reading too much? 

__________________
Learn more about my email list here.
Books I recommend for 8-12 year olds.





12 comments:

  1. Great suggestions! Once my dad was struggling to get us all to clean the house and said in frustration, "No more reading for pleasure!" We all thought it was hilarious.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks! :D Once my mom told my brother he was grounded from the library.

      Delete
  2. Really fantastic post and advice. Thanks so much!

    ReplyDelete
  3. My son is in the 6th grade and LOVES to read. He'll read a book in the car ride to school even when his friends are with us. I have recently asked him to put it away to join our conversation. The kids are allowed and encouraged to read books at school after they finish their work. This is the age that kids are becoming more responsible for their work. Although he is very intelligent, I've had two teachers say that he's an excellent student except that he is too eager to get his reading book out, sometimes rushing through tests or not completing classwork at school. My husband and I decided to not allow books for reading at school, but trying to determine the best replacement for the "free time."

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for sharing this! Now my mind is cycling through all kind of possibilities for what he could do instead of reading. Something with his hands? Knitting? Or is that likely to cause teasing? Writing, working on a story of his own? Maybe drawing and doodling!

      Delete
    2. Writing is an excellent idea. We are going to allow him to take a book the first quarter of the new school year. If we see he hasn't figured out how to control his craving for reading at inappropriate times along with its effects, I will encourage writing. We've discussed writing a book!

      Thank you for your feedback!

      Delete
  4. I have a 12 year old 7th grader who is a voracious reader. She is reading books she has read already 3-4 times. Trust me I could have much bigger problems with my middle schooler than this but I just need to get it a bit under control. In the last 24 hours she has forgotten two assignments for school because she was reading too much. She got them done in time but that was after a few hours of reading and then having a "uh-oh" moments. She is a gifted student and is getting straight A's in an accelerated program so school isn't an issue. She reads in the car on the way to soccer, school, grocery store, etc...it is getting a bit obsessive. The other day she was having a melt down because we wouldn't let her finish a chapter before taking a shower...she had read the book 3 times already. Ugh...
    My worry is social skills. She is forgetting that there is a world around her that needs her in it. Her world is becoming the book. We have set limits, time and that usually fails...hard to punish a kid who reads too much! Any additional ideas?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. - YES! I have three pieces of advice for you. But first let me say that only your family can decide what is right for you and you are going to need to work together in order to work this out. Your daughter is probably going to be completely fine -- what you describe sounds a lot like my husband's sister at the same age. Now she is happily married and working full time and still reading. It's because she has learned self control. Your daughter can learn this, but of course like all adolescents it will take time. Be persistent, and get her involved in her own development.

      - Advice #1: Swap "books" for "video games." In the paragraph you wrote me, it is clear that your daughter is reading for entertainment. So let's swap everything books for another popular entertainment, video games. We'll change the gender, too.

      - "I have a 12 year old 7th grader who is a voracious gamer. He is playing games he has already beaten 3-4 times. Trust me I could have much bigger problems with my middle schooler than this but I just need to get it a bit under control. In the last 24 hours he has forgotten two assignments for school because he was playing too much. He got them done in time but that was after a few hours of gaming and then having an "uh-oh" moment. He is a gifted student and is getting straight A's in an accelerated program so school isn't an issue. He plays in the car on the way to soccer, school, grocery store, etc...it is getting a bit obsessive. The other day he was have a melt down because we wouldn't let him finish a level before taking a shower. He had beaten the game 3 times already. Ugh... My worry is social skills. He is forgetting that there is a world around him that needs him in it. His world is becoming the game. We have set limits, time and that usually fails. It's hard to punish a kid who plays too many video games! Any ideas?"

      - Wow. Reading that with a little bit of a swap makes it clear that there is a problem here, right? There is a problem. Of the ones i wrote about in the article above, I would say it's closest to #2 "I can't get her to help out" except that you're not even asking her to help out, just asking her to remember school assignments and not backtalk to you when you ask her to pause.

      - Advice #2: Involve her in solving this problem. Tell her you have something important to ask her about. Read the above paragraph to her (the one where I swapped books for video games). Ask her what these parents should do to help their son. She will probably say they should take away his video games. Ask her for how long. And what about after he gets them back? Won't he just go back to his old habits? How can they help him learn the self control he needs? Once she's given her ideas, reveal to her that this paragraph is actually about her (she might have already guessed). Read her the real one that you wrote to me. Work with her to make a plan for how she is going to act when a "too much reading" situation comes up.

      Delete
    2. (continued)

      - Advice #3 Give her more chores. Why do I say this? Because you said "she is forgetting that there is a world around her that needs her in it." I want you to remind her of that at least twice a day be requiring her to do real things that really need to get done. Don't give her chores that are just personal responsibilities. Give her chores that help out the family. Chores that if she doesn't do them, someone else will have to do them, or the whole family will be waiting on her, or that she can see are important. In The Parenting Breakthrough (the book above) here are some of the chores that are 12-year-olds should be able to do: clean the refrigerator, make and keep own haircut appointments, straighten closets and drawers, make several main dishes, iron her own clothes, mow the lawn, clean windows, etc. Obviously every kid is different, but yours is a gifted learner, and I'm sure she can do these things if you teach her. You could even grade her, if that would make it more fun for both of you. "Hmm, I give these windows an 85%. Would you like a re-do?"

      - It is worth it. Your job as parents is to raise an independent adult, and that takes work. So it won't be easy. But it is important. Nobody else can teach her self-control and independence like her parents can. And it is your responsibility as parents to do it. When my husband and I were talking about your comment over breakfast he said, "It's worth it to get a B in middle school in order to learn self control." Put her work at home above her school work. Raise your expectations of her. You can do it.

      Delete
  5. Alysa, thank you! I love the transition idea you shared about asking about the book as they reenter the real world. What a great two-fer idea, transition for her and info for me. Also looking up reviews on the books - duh! Fantastic!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You're welcome, Debi! I'm glad you found some good ideas here. Your comment made my day!

      Delete

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...